Background: AARS2 encodes the mitochondrial protein alanyl-tRNA synthetase 2 (MT-AlaRS), an important enzyme in oxidative phosphorylation. Variants in AARS2 have previously been associated with infantile cardiomyopathy. Case summary: A 4-year-old girl died of infantile-onset dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in 1996. Fifteen years later, her 21-year-old brother was diagnosed with DCM and ultimately underwent heart transplantation. Initial sequencing of 15 genes discovered no pathogenic variants in the brother at the time of his diagnosis. However, 9 years later re-screening in an updated screening panel of 129 genes identified a homozygous AARS2 (c.1774C > T) variant. Sanger sequencing of the deceased girl confirmed her to be homozygous for the AARS2 variant, while both parents and a third sibling were all found to be unaffected heterozygous carriers of the AARS2 variant. Discussion: This report underlines the importance of repeated and extended genetic screening of elusive families with suspected hereditary cardiomyopathies, as our knowledge of disease-causing mutations continuously grows. Although identification of the genetic etiology in the reported family would not have changed the clinical management, the genetic finding allows genetic counselling and holds substantial value in identifying at-risk relatives.